A substrata of disaster. The Salient.
by Michele Spagnolo

portfolio special mention call 'URBANAUTICA INSTITUTE AWARDS 2020', 2020

In October, 1914, early in the First World War, a Salient was born. The German Army came to a halt, just at the edge of the semicircle formed by the hills surrounding the Belgian town of Ypres. Satisfied with their position, the soldiers entrenched themselves, awaiting a more propitious moment to advance. The French, Belgians and British on the other side, took advantage of the pause provided by the Germans. They too seized the opportunity to improve their defence of the Flemish stronghold, which they had managed to retain at great cost to life. It was exactly in those few days that the Ypres Salient was formed. One hundred years later, on a rainy October day, I walked down a muddy track running alongside the Bellewaerde Ridge, just a few kilometres away from Ypres. They were the first steps of a long path, which led me to travel more than 1,000 kilometres over the area of the Salient. In the four years of the centenary of the First World War. It was in an effort to have a better understanding of this unique area – one of the First World War’s most iconic landscapes – and tell its story with photography. I sought out signs, sometimes hidden, sometimes still evident, left by the conflict in the countryside extending around Ypres. It is these signs which have ultimately created this very special landscape. For me, the Salient was more than anything an endless source of tales. Practically every square metre of the area is associated with an event or a memory. On a number of occasions, this profusion gave me the impression that my journey was not a mere trip through the physical space - which I had travelled over - but also a journey through different “dimensions.” My project was to create a map of the Salient, which can depict and document not only the visible, present countryside I have travelled across, but also the absent landscapes which memory has revived. At the time I began walking along the pathways of the Salient, it already seemed crystal clear to me what the American artist, Robert Smithson, had meant when he said, “Each landscape, no matter how calm and lovely, always conceals a substrata of disaster.” I have used this sentence as a “guide” throughout this journey. These places, which appear so calm, have never recovered from that huge disaster. They are marked by it forevermore. The roads leading to the hill have been renamed, “Suicide Road” and “Hun’s Walk”; the copses “Battle Wood” and “Sanctuary Wood.” These war-related names have replaced older designations. The boundaries of the fields today, still follow the broken lines of trenches. The lakes with their croaking frogs are actually large craters created by bombs. The war has fashioned the geography anew. General Plumer’s self-fulfilling prediction which he made before the Battle of Messines holds true to this day, “Gentlemen, we may not make history tomorrow, but we shall certainly change the geography.” Battle scars are not the only traces permanently left on this landscape by man. Several generations have, in various ways, commemorated, recounted tales and reminisced about the war and its victims, victories, defeats and tragedies. Dozens of cemeteries, mausoleums, obelisks and other monuments are dotted about the countryside. One summer afternoon, a hundred years after the beginning of the Battle of Passchendaele, in a puddle at the border of a field, I found a large fragment of rusty metal with ragged edges. I picked it up and felt its weight for a few moments. It was as big as my hand and extremely heavy. Probably the shard of an artillery shell. Despite the extensive mine clearance operations carried out at the end of the conflict, today there are still hundreds and hundreds of fragments like this one – shrapnel, grenades, shards, projectiles, bombs – which surface from the mud. The people there call this the “Iron Harvest.” On another day, not far from one of the big mine craters near Wijtschaete, the face of a man in uniform seemed to be watching me, from a small photograph which was tied to a tree with a piece of string. It had been printed on ordinary paper and, although it had been laminated, the rain had almost entirely erased it. Who had put that photo there at the foot of a tree in a little Flemish wood? Since then, I have found dozens of small photos, often poorly printed and weathered so much that the faces of these young men who had fallen during fighting were almost or totally worn away. Not only collective memory – the common imagination associated with the war – but also a plethora of individual, private recollections, which are yet more moving, put their signature on the landscape, marking out places. An eerie unease, a sense of sadness and inexplicable melancholy hanged in the air. Like a ghost. For me, walking was not only a necessary, but a conscious act. I was convinced that only by going on foot would I be able to comprehend the numerous aspects which make up this landscape. By walking, I wanted not only to travel through and visit the “space” in which the events that made the Salient so famous had taken place, but also turn back the “time” which separated me from those years – return to the present to observe, listen and feel. To use the words of Tim Ingold and Jo Lee Vergunst: “Since to follow a trail is to remember how it goes, making one’s way in the present is itself a recollection of the past…onward movement is itself a return.” Walk to remember. Walk on a quest for a memory or memories. The memory evoked by a landscape which continues, resiliently, to reveal battle scars. The strange “souvenirs” recalled by metal fragments, which remind us even today of the horror of mechanised warfare. The private memories of those who touchingly carry on, paying tribute to their fallen antecedents. Perhaps it is also the memory of those who died in this war; a memory which, akin to a spirit, continues to hang in the bluish air thickening around the birches, that stand guard before a cemetery at twilight. On a summer’s evening.


share this page
   also from URBANAUTICA INSTITUTE AWARDS 2020
portfolio
I See Nothing
Frank Marshal
portfolio
The leaves will fall from the sky
Jenia Fridlyand
portfolio
Temporal Nature
Matthew Jessie
portfolio
Istinto
Gabriele Onere
portfolio
The Aesthetics of Transformation: Highway (re)Construction
Steven Benson
portfolio
A Bloom in the Eye of the Storm
Guillaume Tomasi
portfolio
THE PLEASURE OF RUINS
Manuela Naddeo
portfolio
Three houses
Nicole Marchi
portfolio
A Sleeping Place
Patrizia Succetti
portfolio
Il Fiume
Laura Volpato
portfolio
Marassi
Tony McAteer
portfolio
These Walls
Ian Potter
portfolio
Rare Earth Image Bank
David Kelley
portfolio
Makeshift
Pawel Starzec
portfolio
LA LIGNE D'EAU
Sara Palmieri
portfolio
Q
Giulia Vanelli
portfolio
A necessary space
Sergio Leone
portfolio
The Ugly Duckling
Giulia Vanelli
portfolio
The Drake
Tamara Reynolds
portfolio
Chiamata Interurbana
Davies Zambotti
portfolio
271 DAYS. ROME'S RESISTANCE
Daniele Molajoli
portfolio
Between the Levee and the River
Jennifer Colten
portfolio
Journey to the Lowlands
Valeria Sacchetti
portfolio
The New Company Town
Sam Oberter
portfolio
Independencia
Max Arens
portfolio
Frequency
Cristian Ordóñez
portfolio
Last Night The Sun Came
Jacob Black
portfolio
Stranded
Polina Shubkina
portfolio
If a Falling Tree Starts Making Noise - Communities of Tree Protectors in London
Sabrina Merolla
portfolio
Uprooted
Andrea Carnevali
portfolio
The Riesthal Gardens
Immelé Anne
portfolio
Ignat 2020
Mircea Sorin Albutiu
portfolio
Earth not a globe
Philippe Braquenier
portfolio
NATA STANCA
Giulia Bernardi
portfolio
Coastline
Masato Ninomiya
portfolio
Circus
Sabrina Caramanico
portfolio
The Garden
Alessandro Cirillo
portfolio
The Stone Time
Breno Rotatori
portfolio
Radure
Chiara Arturo
portfolio
Fragile like granite
Matteo Fiorentino
portfolio
Esercizi Obbligatori atto II - Compulsory Exercises act II
Marilisa Cosello
portfolio
Therapy
Tommaso Sacconi
portfolio
ČAROLIJE ( MAGIC)
Tijana Pakic
portfolio
Into The Warm Nothing
Fleur Jakobs
portfolio
PARADISE
Gian Marco Sanna
portfolio
Riverside girls
Chiara Fossati
portfolio
Suspended landscapes
Francesca Canu
portfolio
Don't be deceived by appearances
Benina Hu
portfolio
Pánta rheî
Paolo Michelotti
portfolio
Chrysalis
Annamaria Belloni
portfolio
Aisle Seat
Ilias Lois
portfolio
peripher
Andreas Tschersich
portfolio
SALT AND LIGHT
Ivan Petrović
portfolio
These Dark Mountains
Giulia Degasperi
portfolio
To pick up a stone
Claudia den Boer
portfolio
Nascentes morimur
Fabio D’Arsiè
portfolio
No Lone Zone
Adam Reynolds
portfolio
Occupied Territories
Giorgio Cecca
portfolio
Particles
Boris Loder
portfolio
Temporary encounter
Van Caneghem Dieter
portfolio
That is where I’m writing you this pretty card
Olga Laz
portfolio
Morning Walks
Roelant Meijer
portfolio
Soft Nostalgia
Suzanne van der Borg
portfolio
Pianura (Plain)
Andrea Arduini & Daniele Pilenga
portfolio
THE OTHER BRIDGES
Matteo Orlandi
portfolio
HOME
Giancarlo Pradelli
portfolio
#AdolescentContent
Sara Esposito
portfolio
Insecta
Rich Cutler
portfolio
Case Parcheggio
Andrea Petrosino
portfolio
Tacaná
Antonio Rodriguez
portfolio
Ora
Sébastien Arrighi
portfolio
Here are lions
Jan Locus
portfolio
Inner Place
Simone Padelli
portfolio
A Peculiar Convenience
Rosie Barnes
portfolio
Journée Ordinaire
Thomas Gauthier
portfolio
Greetings from the epicenter, Borgata, Siracusa.
LUC RABAEY
portfolio
E' rimasto solo il marciapedi
Giovanni Presutti
portfolio
The Butterfly Effect
Louisiana van Onna
portfolio
Trama familiare. Racconto di un oggetto
Noemi Civiero
portfolio
Gli Stati delle Anime
Giovanni Emilio Galanello
portfolio
Ciucciuì
Priscilla Pallante
portfolio
Memories of the Future
Benedikt Partenheimer
portfolio
Bikur Holim
Stav Tsur
portfolio
A Threefold Experience of Spaces
Daan Russcher
portfolio
Terra incognita (*)
Spiros Zervoudakis
portfolio
Greetings from the Parade Ground
Marcel Rauschkolb
portfolio
Ashes
Jake Mein
portfolio
The Street Becomes
Jaime Permuth
portfolio
Pego Negro
Bruno Silva
portfolio
Accùra
Laura Misuraca
portfolio
Conditions for an Unfinished Work of Mourning: Wretched Yew
Dawn Roe
portfolio
The Voice of the Cicada
Vasileios Vasileiou
portfolio
As the Blackbird died twice
Ragna Arndt Maric
portfolio
Ruined Ruins
Alon Koppel
portfolio
Zameen Asmaan Ka Farq (Hindi/Urdu: 'As far apart as the Earth is from the Sky')
Marc Ohrem-Leclef
portfolio
Guarita
Stefan Schmeling
portfolio
Familiar
Garrett Williams
portfolio
Earthquakes
Igor Londero
portfolio
Landforms
Neal Johnson
portfolio
Bright Spot
Shawn Records
portfolio
When the Trees Are Gone
Diana Cheren Nygren
portfolio
Messa In Sicurezza
Marco Gatta
portfolio
Interior Walk
Mireille Schellhorn
portfolio
Remains
Paolo D'Amato
portfolio
In Limbo
Mimi Mollica
portfolio
On Land and Water
Penelope Thomaidi
portfolio
When we grow up
Kevita Junior
portfolio
Cinema
Fernando Brito
portfolio
Morivo d'abbandono
Tiziano Demuro
portfolio
POST-MOSCOW [2019-ongoing]
Fyodor Konukhov
portfolio
At Night The Salmon Move
Esther Gabrielle Kersley
portfolio
Violently Happy
Alec Von Bargen
portfolio
New Buildings
Dmytro Prutkin
portfolio
Off the Mark
Diego Brambilla
portfolio
Gibellina 1968 - otto minuti dopo le tre
Giuseppe Iannello
portfolio
Frontières
Taillez Maxime
portfolio
Ontic Glow
Lisa Di Donato
portfolio
To the banks of certain rivers
Francesco Federico Natalucci
portfolio
Cornucopia
Panos Charalampidis & Mary Chairetaki
portfolio
Nativity scenes
Marco Rigamonti
portfolio
make hummus not walls
Matteo Portigliatti
portfolio
Foundation Home for Portuguese Emigrants in the World
Nelson Miranda
portfolio
Suburb 5
Gianmarco Caroti
portfolio
Lozhok
Nick Tarasov
portfolio
The Leftovers of Eden
Zsolt Balázs
portfolio
Walking Around
Nemanja Zdravkovic
portfolio
KUTHO
Andrea Alkalay
portfolio
Where the sea runs through.
Cédric Dasesson
portfolio
Serendipity
Nicola Buonomo
portfolio
Passing Time
Richard Chivers
portfolio
Crescita
Colin Malcolm Dutton
portfolio
Monsoons never cross the mountains
Camillo Pasquarelli
portfolio
God to Go West
Daniel George
portfolio
BAUXITE - (human futility)
Federico Patrocinio
portfolio
Un luogo bello
Alessandro Mallamaci
portfolio
Qui non c'é nessuno
Lorenzo Mini
portfolio
Every Exits And Junctions On The Motorway A4
Mirko Lamonaca
portfolio
River Under Earth
Dmitry Ermakov
portfolio
Thousand shades of blue between us, Bangkok
Alessio Pellicoro
portfolio
Vanished
Claudia Orsetti
portfolio
Silent Occupation
Saccoccio Romain
portfolio
Bee Generation
Marco Ristuccia
portfolio
Where The Echo Still resound
Jacopo Brunello
portfolio
La Corsa dei Ceri di Gubbio (Ceri’s race)
Giuseppe Cardoni
portfolio
Berlin and its difficult relation with History
Luca Girardini
portfolio
Warmer Than The Sun
Elise Corten
portfolio
PACIFICVM
Matteo Palmieri
portfolio
Schermi provvisori
Giovanni Orlando
portfolio
Definirti è limitarti
Matteo Spertini
portfolio
Yinanping
Qiushi Chen
portfolio
Familiar: Archivio Affettivo Siciliano (an emotional archive of Sicily)
Camilla Glorioso
portfolio
Air-Conditioned Nation


portfolio
From The Goat Land
Claudia Professione
portfolio
Family Portraits
Maria Mavropoulou
portfolio
Hiroshima mon amour
Martina Elizabeth Di Carlo
portfolio
Zimmerfrei
Francesco Biasi
portfolio
Devil's Promenade
Antone Dolezal & Lara Shipley
call
URBANAUTICA INSTITUTE AWARDS 2020
portfolio
The Nam Ou from the series The Corridor of Opportunity - landscape stories from Lao PDR
Tessa Bunney
portfolio
Post Encounters
Tal Ben Avi
portfolio
Saeta
Curro Rodriguez Sanchez
portfolio
Elements
Fulvio Orsenigo
portfolio
Silver City, Lode of Lead
Jamie Hladky
portfolio
When the upper lip loses its softness
Bettina Koller
portfolio
Hanging on the Wall
Jake Romm
portfolio
On Wilderness And The Captive Gaze
Dario Bosio
portfolio
How to Build a Mountain
Anne Bergman
portfolio
Something and Nothing
Carlo Chiapponi
portfolio
By the Creek, Opposite of a Meadow
Michaela Nagyidaiová
portfolio
High Garden
Tom Spach
portfolio
Awaiting the Bridge
Maja Nydal
portfolio
Sotto lo stesso cielo
Giammario Corsi
portfolio
By th silent line
Pierre Folk
portfolio
Umane Tracce
Nicola Paccagnella
portfolio
BRAZILKA
Emanuela Colombo
portfolio
Sunny days / A true story
Kosmas Pavlidis
portfolio
Impermanence: Louisiana’s Fraying Coast
Daniel Kariko
portfolio
A Return to Foul Bay
Alexandra Majerus
portfolio
SIN
Matteo Capone
portfolio
The New City
Douglas Ljungkvist
portfolio
The Land of Elephants
Silvy Amorim Crespo
portfolio
Uniformity
Orestis Seferoglou
portfolio
Bunkers
Filippo Bardazzi
portfolio
Megalomania - Delusions of Grandeur
Simon Van Geel
portfolio
NSENENE
Michele Sibiloni
portfolio
Estamos na Luta
Tommaso Rada
portfolio
Satan's Casual Demise
Mark Sawrie
portfolio
Holyhead -Sea Change?
Robert Law
portfolio
Ototeman
Arianna Savo
portfolio
Slowly Westward: A Journey Through A Folded Landscape
Mark McGuinness
portfolio
Sclavanie
Davide Degano
portfolio
Grab Your Bibles, There's a Storm Comin'
Evan Perkins
portfolio
Pai Mar
Hermano Noronha
portfolio
DISMANTLED
Ian Harris
portfolio
.No.Code. - ELEMENTARY HIEROPHANIES AND DECODING OF THE GAZE
Stefano Parrini
portfolio
Blue Bar
Matteo Di Giovanni
portfolio
Telepath
Michele Vittori
portfolio
Collectus
Simone Foglia
portfolio
GEOPHAGIA
Mariano Monea
portfolio
Chronos
Alberto Ceresa
portfolio
The untangled tales
Michelle Piergoelam