USUS FRUCTUS ABUSUS _ La Blanche et la Noire
by Gloria Oyarzabal

portfolio shortlisted call 'Urbanautica Institute Awards 2023', 2023
Category: Memories and Traditions


In Roman Law, ownership was defined as the absolute, perpetual, full and exclusive possession of an object or corporeal entity. USUS was the right to use it according to its destination or its nature, FRUCTUS was the right to receive its fruits, and ABUSUS was its disposition based on the capacity for modifying, selling or destroying the object or given entity. Museums originated as institutions more than 300 years ago, when certain royal collections were made accessible to the great public. They became instrumental for defining the identity of nations. And bearing in mind the outstanding colonialist origin of many of their collections, then conflict with History narrative, the creation of knowledge and, consequently, collective and individual memory, becomes unavoidable. Passing in review the historicity and the historiography of the relation between anthropology and the museum collections assembled from a despoiling colonial past, it becomes relevant how these spaces have reinforced exotism and distinction, intrinsically related to supremacist discourses. Museums as creators of imaginaries, as institutions that aren’t and have never been neutral, have but benefited from the exhibited objects and artifacts. Is the museum concept universal? Let’s look behind the curtain. Untie to tie. Responsibility for the risky and far-fetching representation of the black woman body in Western Art can be asserted. A persistent portrayal perpetuating stereotypes of black sexuality -bold, available and subservient-, reinforcing its exoticization, allowing cultural appropriation, marking out hierarchical differences and, as a result, constructing race. Eternal odalisques. Originally slaved women who served in the grand houses, they served the Orientalist school to feed a discrediting imaginary, with erotic images of women in a vague "Orient", evoking a life of luxury and indolence. A life far removed from a XIX Century industrial society and XXI Century norms of representation of race and gender. The odalisque leads to a broader discussion and revision of race in art and art spaces. Black female body has a long history of scrutiny under Western imaginary as early as the XVI Century, being labelled under the white gaze as a sexually deviant, primitive, subhuman, hyper-sexual, an uncontrollably erotic creature… The extensive records of its oppression are characteristically rooted in a history of slavery, colonialism and ethnographic display, creating a collective imaginary based on an overwhelming colonial archive. Over time, this same body has been stripped of its autonomy, purged from intellectual spaces and exposed raw as a "bizarre" public spectacle, being reduced to a mere sum of its parts. How does the colonial endeavour play out across the female body, aesthetically hiding the violence just beneath the surface? Then comes my enthrallment with La Blanche et la Noire, the painting by Félix Vallotton (1913). Inspired by Manet’s Olympia and Ingres’ Odalisque à l’esclave, it depicts the Sapphic love between a sylph and a black woman, but unlike his predecessors, Vallotton dispenses with all exotic references. It is the familiar reclining nubile nude of Art History, frozen in time and laid out for voyeuristic pleasure of a post-coital doze, cheeks ruddied from exertion. Embedded in this dyad before us comes an Orientalist fear and desire for interracial erotic fantasy, tempered by the suggestion of illicit and transgressive relations. In a retro-futuristic version, a two-voice dialogue around gender, race and colonialism emerges between them as they read ‘Afrotopia’ by Felwine Sarr (co-creator with Benedict Savoy of the report commissioned by French President Emmanuel Macron of the issue of looted objects in French museums, notably the Quai Branly Museum) and ‘Loot: Britain and the Benin Bronzes’ by Barnaby Phillips. Questions of spoliation, hegemonic narratives, race and gender are addressed based on the concept of ownership. Returning what has been plundered and looted, both in terms of objects and identity, is it an urgent, universal and feasible question for everyone? Restitution, reparation, recontextualization... who has agency to give, return, adjudicate, rename? “Things are working out…towards their dazzling conclusions…” Our Siter Killjoy, 1977 Ama Ata Aidoo


share this page
   also from Urbanautica Institute Awards 2023
portfolio
Smarrimento/Apparizione
Serena Perrone
portfolio
Never ending Buenos Aires / Buenos Aires infinita
Lorenzo Zoppolato
portfolio
Lou païsatge dë marmo
Enrico Perassi
portfolio
Kingdoms of Uncertainties
Jade Joannès
portfolio
Littorea
Vasily Pindyurin
portfolio
Endure
Chiara Benzi
portfolio
NOSSA SENHORA DA NAZARÉ
Gianfranco Gallucci
portfolio
La transversale
Labrousse Yannick
portfolio
Soon as the Golden Harvest quits the Plain
Thomas Dryden-Kelsey
portfolio
The Emptiness Around
Vito Renò
portfolio
Chalk Streams
Ellie Davies
portfolio
Coastal Mammoth
Pengkuei Ben Huang
portfolio
D'apres nature
Stefano Canetta
portfolio
Postcards from the Dolomites
Massimo Crivellari
portfolio
QT8, incredibly close
Valentina Casalini
portfolio
Scarp
Aaron Yeandle
portfolio
Am I Another You?
Laura Cobb
portfolio
Nel quasi invisibile
Alessio Pellicoro
portfolio
Di la de aghe
Abel Picogna
portfolio
Buits Verds / Green voids
Anna Fontanet Castillo
portfolio
The Sunny Side of the Island
Harry Compton
portfolio
Gesù ti ama
Adriano Zanni
portfolio
La Ronde des Hirondelles
Florence Cuschieri
portfolio
Garden Of Elsewheres
Guglielmo Cherchi
portfolio
Empty Table
Konstantinos Koutsonikolas
portfolio
I saw a tree bearing stones in the place of apples and pears
Emilia Martin
portfolio
I Can Feel You Dreaming
Taylor Galloway
portfolio
All Memories Fade
Lynn Bierbaum
portfolio
Perfect Brightness, Eternal Spring
Dustin Lin
portfolio
Almost Heaven
Jeffrey Robins
portfolio
We kept on dancing like it didn't matter
Giannina Urmeneta Ottiker
portfolio
Lifelong Ember
Grade Solomon
portfolio
Drive-Thru
Drew Waters
portfolio
The Commune
Nick Teplov
portfolio
The Shadow Line
Michal Korta
portfolio
In the Blackbird's Fields
Tom Videlo
portfolio
That silence beyond the window
Marco Battezzati
portfolio
Our Town… fading glimpses of the Midwest
Robin W Bailey
portfolio
Intersect
Winni Wintermeyer
portfolio
Plagio
Attilio Fiumarella
portfolio
When the old river turns, we hide, we seek
Dalmonia Rognean
portfolio
Dunes' Edge
Thomas Iacobucci
portfolio
Msheireb Downtown Doha
Tony McAteer
not published yet
portfolio
DEL/SYS_32
Holly Von Ruden Holly
portfolio
Pillar: No More Mud in Our Eyes
Andrés de Varona
portfolio
Reformation
Joaquin Palting
portfolio
The Messengers
Filippo Bardazzi Laura Chiaroni
portfolio
DC Alleys
Daniel Weingrod
portfolio
Mother Earth: nevertheless she persisted
Diana Cheren Nygren
portfolio
Perpetual memories
Filipe Bianchi
portfolio
Smoke Screen
Rob Carter
portfolio
Children of factories
Gianluca Rossetti
portfolio
Lasciar crescere l'erba
Fulvia Bernacca
portfolio
Zero Responder


portfolio
Sunday Service
Josefine Rauch
portfolio
Alpine gardens
Weiner Cyrille
portfolio
When a meter equals a bahr
Matthew Conboy
portfolio
The return


portfolio
Same Same But Different
Loic Vendrame
portfolio
Lost Lake
Marion Belanger
portfolio
Snowbed
Georgia Ponirakou
portfolio
Now Here, Images of Nowhere.
Matt Ault
portfolio
Future Holdings
Matthew Conboy
portfolio
Keep unwind
Valerii Konkov
portfolio
Home Sweet Home
Pietro Grossi
portfolio
Unseasonably Warm
Alexander Williamson
portfolio
Alto Garda. Nuovi paesaggi
Paolo Calzà
portfolio
Florecer
Sabina Candusso
portfolio
Certain Ways Out
Irem Baskan
portfolio
GOYANG LOVE
Ley Matthias
portfolio
A Incompletude para além do fim (“Incompleteness beyond the end”)
Carlos Barradas
portfolio
Fantastic animals
Kasia Ślesińska
portfolio
Qui stiamo Qui restiamo
Simone Tommaselli
portfolio
Blank cities
Viola Hertelova
portfolio
Y è pi de ten que de via - C'è più tempo che vita
Greta Valente
portfolio
Perché ti ricordi sempre
Francesca Faulin
portfolio
RAWA
Krzysztof Szewczyk
portfolio
Epiphany
Spiros Zervoudakis
portfolio
Temporary Landscapes
Łukasz Szamalek & Anką Gregorczyk
portfolio
Wasser_S_Turm
Timmermans Valerie
portfolio
Come spirto in un'ampolla
Enzo Castellucci
portfolio
Counter Earth
Elena Aya Bundurakis
portfolio
Nostos (The Sea is an Archeology)
Costanza Santilli
portfolio
UNDERCOVER
Onnis Luque
portfolio
Hidden Dimensions
Anna Yeroshenko
portfolio
The Absence and Presence of the Berlin Wall
Gesche Würfel
portfolio
Awali
Sue Vaughton
portfolio
Stavo Pensando Al Mare - I was thinking about the sea
Giorgia Dal Molin
portfolio
Blank Verse
Maria Siorba
portfolio
Astatale
Carlo Stella
portfolio
The furthest point was home / Il pinto più lontano era casa
Danilo Murru
portfolio
Black is the river
Pietro Millenotti
portfolio
How to Understand a Rock.
Kate Schneider
portfolio
Mirrors
Imantas Selenis
portfolio
Wadden Sea
Düllberg Leon
portfolio
Montefurtì
Michele De Santis
portfolio
Mysterious Clean Island
Andy Hughes
portfolio
The lineage
Antoine Le Roux
portfolio
Citizens
Philip Heying
portfolio
Make Something Beautyful from Your Trauma
Irina Vosgerau
portfolio
Cushioned Walls
Jacopo Papucci
portfolio
The absence of the train driver
Marcel Rauschkolb
portfolio
Last Stop on this Train
Brian Rose
portfolio
Termini
Gabriel Orlowski
portfolio
FLUCTUATIONS
Ibai Etxezarraga Alvarez
portfolio
Fuoco, Pignata e Sciuscielli


portfolio
A Shadow in the Shape of a House
Lena Holzer
portfolio
Kletos
Niccolò Del Pizzo
portfolio
Mondrian's Nightmares
Pavel Mikhailovskii
portfolio
FrancescoLatino_ProjectHome
Francesco Latino
portfolio
l'ippocampo
Manuela Naddeo
portfolio
Betonia
Katerina Kouzmitcheva
portfolio
Pays Noir
Jacopo Brunello
portfolio
Mountain Park
Antonio Cunico
portfolio
Now is not the right time
Peter Pflügler
portfolio
[DIS]LOCATI
Collettivo Order#10362 Elisa Bianchi Testoni, Marco Brioni, Umberto Righi
portfolio
Gehavend
Anne Schreutelkamp
portfolio
The Promised Land
Amit Sharma
portfolio
The Sun Sets Midafternoon
Jessica Hays
portfolio
You Are Everything to Me
Angela Crosti
portfolio
Malsicuri simulacri
Elisabetta Scalvini
portfolio
Flowers for Mary
Iris Bergman
portfolio
Gaipecas and Marisqueiros - on a southern beach
Efreu Quintana
portfolio
The Passenger
Benoit Chailleux
portfolio
Cemento Armato
Matteo Angelini
portfolio
Armonia selvaggia
Paolo Artuso
portfolio
BECAUSE THAT'S THE WAY WE LIKE IT
Maria Pateraki
portfolio
Kler - states of presence
Joël Alain Dervaux
portfolio
Us
Stefano Ferrando
portfolio
Imagined Images
Maria Mavropoulou
portfolio
Manifestation of the myth
Mathieu Lion
portfolio
Silenzio
Massimiliano Tempesta
portfolio
Down by the river
Daniela Silvestri
portfolio
R Like ...
Quang Lam
portfolio
The Braccata's Road
Maxime Amat
portfolio
Shanghai fishing
Ralph Steinegger
portfolio
Carsismo
Paul Montagnon
portfolio
Ho visto uomini (?) - I saw men | Have I seen men?
Giorgia Dal Molin
portfolio
Borders
Grigoris Digas
portfolio
Prosféro
Elena Zottola
portfolio
Three Thousand Three Hundred Moments
Maria Quigley
portfolio
Sentinelle Solitarie: le Case Cantoniere
Sofia Podestà
portfolio
Fragments of resilience
Giulia Barbero
portfolio
Hyperarousal
Bettina Koller
portfolio
Acceleration Lake
Patricio Davila
portfolio
871
Francesca Cugno & Gaia Maggio
portfolio
LIMO
Maria Selene Clemente & Christian Pardini
portfolio
Eldorado
Elisa Chiari
portfolio
Le désert
Pauline Dupin
portfolio
Rosacroce
Francesca Cugno
portfolio
A Sight (Not) To See


portfolio
Solidi
Giancarlo Pradelli
portfolio
Living in the Suburbs
Yan Jiacheng
portfolio
ethnographies
Simion Felicia
portfolio
At rest
Ralph Steinegger
portfolio
Holding on
Tommaso Sacconi
portfolio
Access The Invisible
Mircea Sorin Albutiu
portfolio
lutruwita (The Apple Isle)
Felix Joensson
portfolio
The Mass Hysteria of Cappadocian People
Çağrı Ertem
portfolio
Lullaby of the Present Body
Curro Rodriguez Sanchez
portfolio
Concrete River
Mathew Scott
portfolio
What Is Left
Gonçalo C. Silva
portfolio
A Point in Time
Paul Walsh
portfolio
Timeless
Enzo Crispino
portfolio
Sotto le Pietre, il Sale
Giovanni Emilio Galanello
portfolio
To the Dogs
Rosie Barnes
portfolio
Two Seas
Ikuru Kuwajima
portfolio
As if nothing has happened
Ralph Steinegger
portfolio
By The Lake
Tommy Keith
portfolio
Santa Lucia
Ciro Battiloro
portfolio
A New Monumentality
Rob Stephenson
portfolio
Grained City
Anatoly Suzdaltsev
portfolio
Abbraccio Mortale
Paolo Michelotti
portfolio
The River That Flows In Winter
Jiayue Yu
portfolio
Through the Revolving Door


portfolio
REDUCE-RE
Sebastiano Raimondo
portfolio
A Place to live
Sana Ahmadizadeh
portfolio
A meigàma
Ambra Iride Sechi
call
URBANAUTICA INSTITUTE AWARDS 2023
portfolio
A chance encounter
Paolo Patrizi
portfolio
Strawberry Blue
Marinos Tsagkarakis
portfolio
MICROCLIMA
Luca Mantovani
portfolio
There on heaven's doorsill
Roxana Savin
portfolio
La Festa dell'Equatore
Rosa Lacavalla
portfolio
Messengers and Promises
Lesha Pavlov
portfolio
Eboli
Sebastiano Maielli
portfolio
Montana Road Wreck
Chris M Forsyth
portfolio
The swan that flew away and the song that came back to us.
Margrieta Jeltema
portfolio
Fy Ynys (My Island)
Robert Law
portfolio
A Hurricane Advances Happily
Pedro J. Márquez
portfolio
Kilelle. Towards home.
Ksenia Maksimova
portfolio
On Groundless Fears
Justin Aungst
portfolio
Whether Every Tree's Birthday Falls In the Spring
Geyujing Shen
portfolio
Finibus Terrae
Adriano Nicoletti
portfolio
Zone B
Margaret Dearing
portfolio
A room of one's own
Yanyan Zhao
portfolio
Rovine, mia famiglia
Francesco Federico Natalucci
portfolio
Corviale, Roma
Giuseppe Cardoni
portfolio
Avalanche
Andrew McClees
portfolio
Vertical Utopia
Pierre-Romain Guedj
portfolio
Rotoforo
Luca Baldassari
portfolio
Boja Fauss
Alessandro Truffa
portfolio
THE GREAT FATHER
Camilla de Maffei
portfolio
Uccellaccio
Barbara Rossi
portfolio
Pool Of The Ox's Eye
Jake Husband
portfolio
Fragile - もろい
van Dun Sepp
portfolio
The classics can console. But not enough
Alexandra Majerus
portfolio
Almost like home
Andrey Permitin
portfolio
Aphanismos
Artur Leão
portfolio
In Between Worlds
Jurgen Onland
portfolio
On The Shore
Hara Sklika
portfolio
THE INTIMACY OF EXTINCTION
Marten Slothouwer